© Adobe Stock

Staff scheduling is an essential process for any business that depends on employees to provide products or services to customers. However, staff scheduling can be a source of many problems and difficulties if done poorly and can have negative impacts on various aspects of business performance and sustainability, such as productivity, profitability, customer satisfaction, employee morale, and compliance. 

In this essay, we will look at the main problems and challenges associated with creating a bad rota and how they can affect businesses and their stakeholders. We will also suggest some best practices and solutions to prevent these issues from arising in the first place.

The negative impact of a bad rota for businesses

A staff rota is a schedule that assigns shifts and tasks to employees. A bad staff rota is one that does not match the demand and supply of staff, such as skills, availability, and preferences. A bad staff rota can have negative impacts for businesses in terms of productivity, profitability, customer satisfaction, employee morale, and compliance. Let’s look at a few in detail:

• Productivity: A bad staff schedule can reduce the efficiency and effectiveness of the business operations. This means that the business may not be able to produce or deliver its products or services in a timely and quality manner. For example, if the staff schedule does not allocate enough staff for peak hours, the business may face long queues, delays, or errors that can frustrate the customers and employees. If the staff schedule does not account for unexpected absences or emergencies, the business may struggle to cope or find replacements that can disrupt the workflow and increase the risk of mistakes. If the staff schedule does not assign tasks according to skills and priorities, the business may have unqualified or overburdened staff that can affect the quality and speed of their work.
• Profitability: A bad staff schedule can affect the revenue and cost of the business. This means that the business may not be able to generate enough income or save enough money from its operations. For example, if the staff schedule does not align with the customer demand, the business may lose sales opportunities or face overstaffing issues that can reduce its income and profit margin. If the staff schedule does not optimize the use of labor, the business may waste money on overtime pay or underutilized staff that can increase its expenses and lower its efficiency.
• Customer satisfaction: A bad staff schedule can impact on the reputation and loyalty of the business. This means that the business may not be able to attract and retain its customers or create a positive image in the market. For example, if the staff schedule does not ensure timely and reliable service delivery, the customers may be dissatisfied or switch to competitors that can hurt the business’s sales and growth. If the staff schedule does not allow for flexibility and personalization, the customers may feel ignored or undervalued, which may damage the business’s relationship and trust with them.
• Employee morale: A bad staff schedule can influence the motivation and well-being of the employees. This means that the employees may not be happy or productive in their work or stay loyal to the business. For example, if the staff schedule does not balance the workload and rest periods, the employees may experience stress or burnout that can affect their health and performance. If the staff schedule does not consider the preferences and feedback of the employees, they may feel frustrated or resentful, which may lower their engagement and commitment.
• Compliance: A bad staff schedule can expose the business to legal and ethical risks. This means that the business may violate some laws or regulations or act in an irresponsible or unethical way. For example, if the staff schedule does not comply with employment laws and regulations, such as minimum wage, overtime pay, and health and safety standards, the business may face fines or lawsuits that can harm its finances and reputation. If the staff schedule does not respect the rights and dignity of the employees, such as diversity, inclusion, and privacy, the business may damage its social responsibility and image that can affect its stakeholders and society.

How can I avoid creating a bad rota?

There are many ways for a business to avoid creating a bad rota. Here are a few suggestions:

• Analyse the demand and supply of staff: A business should forecast customer demand and plan staffing needs accordingly. This means that they should estimate how many customers they expect to serve and what kind of products or services they need. Managers should also determine how many staff they need to meet the demand and what kind of skills they require. This means that they will need to evaluate the qualifications and performance of existing staff and identify any gaps or surpluses. They should also consider the availability and preferences of staff in terms of working hours, shifts, and tasks.
• Communicate with employees: Businesses should involve employees in creating and updating staff schedules. This means that they should consult with your employees about availability and preferences and try to accommodate them as much as possible. Managers should also inform them of their shifts and tasks in advance and solicit their feedback and suggestions. This can help create a more accurate and realistic schedule that meets the needs and expectations of staff. Businesses should also be transparent and fair in allocating shifts and tasks by explaining the rationale behind scheduling decisions to avoid favouritism or discrimination.
• Use technology: Businesses should leverage technology to create and manage staff schedules. This means using software or apps (like the award-winning solutions we provide) that can automate scheduling processes, such as generating optimal schedules based on demand and supply, assigning shifts and tasks based on skills and preferences, and updating schedules based on changes and updates. It’s also useful to use software or apps that can track attendance and performance, such as recording clock-in and clock-out times, monitoring productivity and quality, and providing feedback and recognition. They may even generate reports and insights to allow a business to analyse scheduling data, identifying trends and patterns, and provide recommendations and solutions. Many software packages (like ours) can even notify staff of changes and updates, such as sending reminders and alerts, confirming shifts and tasks, and communicating with employees. 
• Review and improve: Businesses should monitor and evaluate staff schedules regularly. This means measuring outcomes in terms of productivity, profitability, customer satisfaction, employee morale, and compliance. Business owners should also identify areas of strength and weakness within staff and schedules and make adjustments as necessary. Part of the review process should also be to seek feedback from customers and employees about staff schedules so that improvements can be made based on their input.

How does scheduling software prevent the creation of a bad rota?

A good scheduling software package like the one we provide can prevent scheduling issues by:

1. Automating the scheduling process and eliminating the need for manual scheduling, thus reducing the time required to create a rota while improving accuracy.
2. Optimizing the use of staff and resources, avoiding understaffing or overstaffing, and saving costs on overtime pay or underutilized staff.
3. Enhancing communication and collaboration with employees, allowing them to view their schedules, make time-off requests, and request shift changes, streamlining the entire scheduling process and reducing miscommunication.
4. Increasing employee satisfaction and engagement, giving them more control over their schedules, respecting their availability and preferences, and rewarding and recognizing their efforts.
5. Tracking attendance and performance, recording clock-in and clock-out times, monitoring productivity and quality, and providing feedback and recognition.
6. Generating reports and insights, analysing scheduling data, identifying trends and patterns, and providing recommendations and solutions.

Here are some answers to some common questions regarding scheduling for small & medium businesses.

What is staff scheduling?

Staff scheduling is the process of creating and managing a schedule that assigns shifts and tasks to employees.

Why is a staff scheduling important?

Staff scheduling is important because it can affect the productivity, profitability, customer satisfaction, employee morale, and compliance of a business.

What are some common challenges or problems with staff scheduling?

Some common challenges or problems with staff scheduling are:

• Understaffing or overstaffing: This occurs when the staff schedule does not match the customer demand or the employee supply. This can result in lost sales opportunities, wasted resources, long queues, delays, errors, or poor service quality.
• Employee dissatisfaction or turnover: This occurs when the staff schedule does not consider the availability or preferences of the employees. This can result in stress, burnout, frustration, resentment, or disengagement among the employees.
• Legal or ethical issues: This occurs when the staff schedule does not comply with the employment laws or regulations or respect the rights or dignity of the employees. This can result in fines, lawsuits, damage to reputation, or social responsibility issues.

What laws govern staff scheduling in the UK?

Here are some of the laws that cover scheduling in the UK:

1. The Working Time Regulations 1998 (WTR), which limit the average working hours to 48 per week, unless the employee opts out. They also require 11 consecutive hours of rest between shifts and one day off every seven days.
2. The Health and Safety at Work Act 1974, which requires employers to provide suitable rest facilities for employees who are working through their breaks.
3. The Employment Rights Act 1996, which gives employees the right to request flexible working arrangements, such as changing their hours or shifts, after 26 weeks of continuous employment.

In conclusion

Staff scheduling is a vital process for any business that relies on employees to deliver products or services. However, staff scheduling can also pose many challenges and problems for both employers and employees, such as scheduling conflicts, employee dissatisfaction, legal or ethical issues, and operational inefficiency. To overcome these challenges and problems, businesses should follow some best practices and use a good quality scheduling software. By doing so, they can create and manage staff schedules that meet their goals and needs as well as those of their customers and employees. 

Free Trial

Staff Scheduling Online Made Simple & Fun

• Create any scheduling pattern
• Click employees into rota schedule
• Staff view by hours, day & week
• Fast & auto schedule planning
• Publish rota via app to employees
• Automatic timesheets from rota schedules

14 days free trial. No credit card required

14 days free trial More on Rota Scheduling

Staff scheduling can be a complex and time-consuming task, but it can also be a rewarding and beneficial one if done properly.